Independent
QuintworX

Retail Media Is Growing Fast. But Are We Measuring What Really Matters?

Sophie Toth on measurement expectations, the value of physical advertising, retailer control of digital inventory and where AI and privacy fit in retail media.

By Sophie Toth

Published

Retail media is growing rapidly, but I wonder whether we are giving ourselves enough time to understand what we are building.

Transforming a physical retail space into a digital advertising environment creates enormous opportunities. More data, more flexibility, new ways to connect with consumers and potentially better ways to measure campaign effectiveness.

But it also brings new expectations.

According to IAB Europe''s latest Attitudes to Retail Media Report, 61% of European buyers identify measurement and reporting as barriers to further investment. Buyers increasingly want unified online and offline reporting, new-to-brand measurement and incrementality.

These are reasonable expectations. But developing reliable measurement capabilities takes time, especially when we are trying to connect physical behaviour with digital advertising data.

Are we allowing enough time to build these capabilities properly, or are we promising more than we can confidently demonstrate?

Are we forgetting the value of physical advertising?

Out-of-home advertising has traditionally been a one-to-many medium. Its strength is reaching people in a particular environment, at a particular moment, without necessarily knowing who each individual is.

Digitalising these spaces gives us something valuable: the ability to respond faster to changing circumstances.

A retailer can adapt advertising to the weather, time of day, local demand, product availability or what is happening in the store. Campaigns no longer need to remain static when the environment around them changes.

I see this as one of the most interesting opportunities for retail media.

Rather than trying to replicate individual targeting from online advertising, why don''t we focus more on making physical advertising relevant to its environment?

We can use technology and AI to understand changing conditions, recommend adjustments and react faster, while preserving the one-to-many value of the medium.

What do we really want to measure?

New-to-brand measurement is a good example.

A retailer may be able to identify that a customer has purchased a product for the first time within its own transaction history. But does that mean the customer is new to the brand, or simply new to buying it from that retailer?

And how do we know whether the advertisement influenced that purchase?

Where purchase data is available, we could combine it with surveys, representative samples or statistical models. We might use multipliers to estimate broader outcomes.

But how reliable are those estimates? What assumptions are we making, and how clearly are we communicating them to buyers?

There is a significant difference between identifying a purchase, attributing it to an advertisement and demonstrating that the advertisement created an additional sale.

We also need to consider the consumer.

An individual may encounter advertising on their phone, television, social media, websites and several screens throughout a shopping journey.

When someone is exposed to advertising at almost every step, what are we really trying to prove about the effectiveness of one particular placement?

Perhaps we need to think more carefully about which outcomes are genuinely measurable and which should remain estimates.

Growing fast, but who controls the space?

There is another risk I believe deserves attention.

Retailers own their physical environments, but that does not automatically mean they control the digital advertising business being developed within them.

Technology providers can play an important role in building and operating these environments. But retailers need to understand who controls their inventory, data, commercial relationships, measurement and ability to make changes.

If a retailer wants to respond immediately to changing circumstances, can it do so independently? Or does every change depend on another provider or disconnected system?

And if the technology partnership changes, what happens to the knowledge, data and commercial capabilities developed along the way?

Owning the physical space should not mean losing control of its digital commercial potential.

Where does AI fit, and what about privacy?

AI can help us process information faster, identify patterns, forecast demand and make advertising more responsive to the environment.

It could also support measurement by analysing aggregated data and helping us understand where campaigns may have contributed to outcomes.

But we should not confuse more sophisticated modelling with greater certainty.

And we should be careful about how much information we believe we need about individual consumers.

Do we really need to identify every person entering a store to make the advertising relevant?

I believe there is considerable value in contextual information, aggregated insights and privacy-conscious measurement without turning physical shopping environments into systems of continuous individual tracking.

AI can support this approach, but privacy still depends on how data is collected, governed and used.

A moment to reflect

I believe retail media has significant potential, but we should not lose sight of what makes physical retail environments different from digital channels.

We have an opportunity to make advertising more dynamic, relevant and responsive to real-world circumstances. We can develop better measurement and give buyers greater confidence.

But we also need to recognise that these capabilities require time, investment, reliable data and transparent methodologies.

Perhaps the future of retail media is not about measuring everything or targeting everyone.

Perhaps it is about understanding the value of the environment, responding intelligently to what happens within it and measuring what we can genuinely demonstrate.

Before we build more capabilities, I think it is worth asking whether we are building the right ones.


References

  1. IAB Europe (3 November 2026), Attitudes to Retail Media Report 2026. Findings on measurement barriers, buyer expectations, incrementality and AI investment. Original research.
  2. IAB Europe (17 September 2026), In-Store Retail Media Measurement Proposals. Proposed approaches to opportunity-to-see, footfall and modelled impressions, recognising different levels of measurement maturity. Original proposals.
  3. ISBA and mediasense (8 September 2026), Digital Retail Media Study. Independent assessment of five major UK retail media networks, identifying differences in attribution, reporting and measurement capabilities. Research findings.
  4. IAB Europe (January 2026), Commerce Media Measurement Standards V2.1. Industry definitions and guidance for incrementality and new-to-brand measurement. Measurement standards.

Editorial disclaimer

This article represents my independent professional opinion. The industry findings are attributed to their original sources; questions, interpretations and proposed approaches are my own. The measurement examples are illustrative, not claims about the performance of any particular retailer or technology provider. The article does not suggest that AI automatically guarantees accurate measurement or regulatory compliance.

Next step

If this describes an asset base you already control, the next step is a diagnosis rather than a technology decision.